Construction Accidents Involving Undocumented Workers

Undocumented construction workers in New York City are the invisible backbone of the industry, performing difficult, dangerous work while lacking fundamental protections afforded to their documented counterparts.

Increased Risks for Undocumented Workers on NY Construction Sites

The pressure to work in the shadows for fear of deportation or job loss creates a perfect storm of exploitation and heightened injury risk. These workers are not only more likely to be assigned the most hazardous duties, but they are also routinely denied access to basic safety measures and training mandated under state and federal laws.

Assigned to High-Risk Jobs Without Adequate Training or Oversight

Undocumented workers frequently end up performing the most perilous tasks on a construction site. These are jobs that documented workers generally refuse due to safety concerns or the technical complexity involved. These include working at extreme heights, demolition, operating heavy machinery, or handling hazardous materials. Despite the inherent dangers, undocumented workers are often untrained or undertrained for these roles.

Many are not given the mandatory 30-hour OSHA construction safety course that New York law requires for certain job sites. Language barriers further compound the issue. Safety instructions are frequently provided only in English, and when workers cannot understand them, the risk of error, injury, or fatality multiplies. Supervisors may not intervene to correct unsafe practices if they view these workers as expendable or replaceable.

Lack of Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) and Site Safety Protocols

Construction companies are legally required to supply adequate safety equipment, including hard hats, harnesses, gloves, goggles, and fall protection systems. However, undocumented workers are sometimes left to supply their own equipment or go without. In some cases, they are discouraged from reporting unsafe conditions out of fear they will be fired or exposed to immigration authorities.

Undocumented laborers may be unaware of their right to a safe workplace. This lack of awareness, combined with an employer’s reluctance to properly document accidents involving these workers, results in severe underreporting of workplace injuries and fatalities.

Types of Dangerous Construction Jobs Commonly Performed by Undocumented Workers in NY

New York’s construction industry is one of the most active and competitive in the nation, driven by high-rise developments, massive infrastructure overhauls, and ongoing renovation projects. Within this demanding ecosystem, undocumented workers are commonly tasked with the following high-risk responsibilities:

Scaffold and High-Rise Work

Many undocumented workers are employed on skyscraper construction and restoration projects that require work on scaffolds or other elevated surfaces. Without proper fall arrest systems, guardrails, or training, these jobs are a leading cause of fatal injuries. Falls from height remain the number one cause of death in the construction industry, particularly in urban environments like NYC.

Demolition and Debris Removal

Demolition jobs carry inherent dangers, such as exposure to falling debris, unstable structures, and hazardous materials like asbestos. Undocumented workers may not be properly briefed on demolition protocols, nor provided with the respiratory protection required for such environments.

Trenching and Excavation

Workers digging foundations or utility lines face the constant threat of trench collapses, which can lead to suffocation or crushing injuries. OSHA regulations are strict in this area, but they may be ignored when undocumented workers are involved, especially on smaller, non-unionized job sites.

Roof Installation and Repairs

Roofing jobs may involve steep slopes, slick surfaces, and exposure to extreme weather conditions. Employers may cut corners by failing to install guardrails or fall protection anchors, especially if the worker is undocumented and unlikely to report violations.

Heavy Machinery Operation

While operating cranes, forklifts, or backhoes typically requires specialized training and certification, undocumented workers are sometimes pressured into these roles without adequate preparation. This not only endangers them but also puts co-workers and pedestrians at risk.

Undocumented Worker Status Does Not Impact Your Right to Claim Injury Compensation in New York

It is a misconception encouraged by unscrupulous employers that undocumented workers cannot seek legal recourse if they are injured on the job. In New York, this is categorically false. Immigration status does not disqualify a worker from receiving compensation for work-related injuries.

Schedule A Free Consultation

Workers’ Compensation Is Available to Undocumented Workers in NY

New York State law mandates that all employers carry workers' compensation insurance. This insurance covers all employees, including those who are undocumented, regardless of their legal work status. Injured workers may be entitled to:

Medical treatment for work-related injuries
Temporary or permanent disability benefits
Lost wage compensation
Death benefits for surviving family members

Importantly, the New York Workers’ Compensation Board does not inquire about immigration status during a benefits determination. Employers who attempt to use a worker’s undocumented status to deny claims may face legal consequences.

Undocumented Workers Can File Third-Party Injury Lawsuits in NY

In addition to workers' compensation, undocumented construction workers may also pursue a third-party personal injury claim if someone other than their direct employer (e.g., a subcontractor, equipment manufacturer, or property owner) contributed to their accident.

These lawsuits can result in far greater compensation beyond what workers' comp offers, including:

Pain and suffering
Full lost wages (not limited like in workers' comp)
Future medical expenses
Loss of earning capacity
Punitive damages in cases of gross negligence

Notably, courts in New York have consistently ruled that immigration status cannot be used as a reason to limit or deny compensation in personal injury lawsuits.

New York Laws Support Maximum Financial Recovery for Undocumented Workers in Construction Accidents

New York has some of the most worker-friendly construction laws in the country, which recognize the dangerous nature of the industry and hold general contractors and property owners to a high standard of safety.

Labor Law § 240 – The Scaffold Law

This law is particularly powerful in protecting undocumented workers involved in height-related accidents. Under Labor Law § 240, contractors and owners (except for one- or two-family homeowners not directing the work) can be held strictly liable for injuries caused by a failure to provide proper fall protection. This means that the injured worker does not need to prove negligence, but only that the law was violated and the violation caused the injury.

In practical terms, if an undocumented worker falls from a scaffold, ladder, or roof and the safety measures were inadequate, the property owner or general contractor can be held 100% liable, regardless of the worker’s immigration status.

Labor Law § 241(6)

This statute applies to construction, excavation, and demolition work. It requires that employers comply with specific safety rules and regulations, including those established by the New York Industrial Code. Violations that result in injury can be the basis for a claim, and again, the worker’s immigration status is irrelevant under the law.

Labor Law § 200

This is a general duty provision that requires employers to provide a safe work environment and take reasonable steps to prevent injury. If a worker is injured due to dangerous conditions or defective equipment, a claim under § 200 may be appropriate.

New York Courts on Immigration and Worker Rights

New York courts have repeatedly affirmed the right of undocumented workers to full and fair compensation. In Balbuena v. IDR Realty LLC (2006), the New York Court of Appeals ruled that immigration status should not prevent injured workers from recovering damages for lost earnings in personal injury lawsuits. The court concluded that denying such claims would encourage unsafe workplace practices and allow employers to exploit undocumented workers with impunity.

This decision remains a cornerstone of labor rights in New York and has made it abundantly clear: justice in construction accident cases must be blind to immigration status.

Frequently Asked QuestionsConstructions Accidents Involving Undocumented Workers

Can I be deported for filing a construction injury claim if I’m undocumented?

No. Filing a workers' compensation claim or a personal injury lawsuit in New York does not trigger immigration enforcement. State agencies like the Workers’ Compensation Board do not share your immigration status with federal authorities. You have the right to seek medical treatment and compensation for your injuries without fear of deportation.

Will my employer find out if I hire a lawyer for my injury in New York?

Not necessarily. A New York construction accident attorney can communicate on your behalf, and legal notices usually go directly to the company’s insurance carrier. Even if your employer learns of your legal action, retaliation for filing a claim is illegal. If they terminate or intimidate you, additional legal remedies may become available.

What if I was paid in cash and don’t have proof of employment in New York?

You can still pursue a claim. Attorneys experienced in undocumented worker cases can help prove your employment through witness statements, text messages, job site photos, or other evidence. The absence of formal payroll records does not bar your right to compensation.

Can I receive lost wage compensation if I used a false name or Social Security number?

Yes. New York courts have ruled that even if false identification was used for employment, injured workers can still recover lost wages. The courts emphasize workplace safety and employer accountability over immigration status or documentation errors.

Are undocumented workers eligible for settlements under New York Labor Law § 240?

Yes. Labor Law § 240 protections apply to all workers, regardless of immigration status. If your injury was caused by a height-related hazard, you may be entitled to substantial compensation under this law, even if you are undocumented.

Choose New York’s Number One Construction Accident Lawyer

Undocumented construction workers face systemic risks on New York’s construction sites, ranging from dangerous job assignments to denial of training, safety gear, and medical care. But while they may be vulnerable in the workplace, they are not powerless in the eyes of the law. New York provides a robust legal framework that allows undocumented workers to recover compensation for their injuries through workers’ compensation and civil lawsuits alike.

Any injured worker, regardless of status, should not be intimidated into silence. New York City construction accident attorney Michael S. Lamonsoff, “The Bull,” has built a reputation on aggressively representing injury victims, including undocumented workers who are typically left behind by the system.

With decades of trial experience and a proven record of multi-million dollar construction accident verdicts and settlements in New York, Mr. Lamonsoff and his team ensure that no worker is invisible, and no injustice goes unchallenged. If you or someone you know has been injured on a construction site, do not let immigration status be a barrier to justice.

Reach out to our trusted, trial-ready legal team that will fight to hold negligent parties accountable for the largest possible financial compensation for your injuries and losses. To schedule your free consultation, call us at 212-962-1020 or fill out this online contact form.